Case file 87-1142 · Port Ashby, Maine · October 3, 1987

The Halvorsen Sapphire

A sapphire vanishes from a locked case while sixty people are in the house.

  • Free
  • 1–4 players
  • 45–60 minutes
  • Difficulty 2/5
  • 10 documents

Letter-size PDF, mostly black ink. Print it at home or read it on a tablet.

The cover of the case file, with a checklist of every document inside

The case

On the evening of Saturday, October 3, 1987, the Halvorsen sapphire brooch was taken from its display case in our front parlor while sixty members of the museum were in the house. The police never charged anyone. The insurer paid the owner $40,000 the following spring, and the file was closed in 1989.

The file holds everything the police gathered, plus a few things they overlooked. Your job is to answer three questions:

  1. Who took the brooch?
  2. How was the case opened?
  3. How did the brooch leave the house?

The suspects

In the file